Chicago Simeon vs. Oak Hill Academy Breakdown

Chicago Simeon vs. Oak Hill Academy Breakdown
Jan 25, 2007, 01:50 pm
DraftExpress takes a look at Chicago Simeon’s resounding upset of #1 ranked Oak Hill Academy last week in Chicago, with in depth breakdowns of the performances of Chicago Simeon’s Derrick Rose and Kevin Johnson, as well as Oak Hill Academy’s Brandon Jennings, Nolan Smith, Alex Legion, and Julian Vaughn.

Chicago Simeon, led by Derrick Rose’s 28 points, 9 assists, and 8 rebounds knocked off Oak Hill Academy 78-75 at the University of Illinois-Chicago. Rose single handedly willed his team to victory, and dominated highly touted junior guard Brandon Jennings. Below are our observations from the top performers in this outstanding high school contest.

Derrick Rose, 6’3 PG, Senior, Chicago Simeon, Signed with Memphis
28 points, 9 assists, 8 rebounds, 9-18 FG

Rodger Bohn

The matchup of Rose and the nation’s top junior point guard Brandon Jennings was a bit disappointing, as Rose dominated the entire game and Jennings was held scoreless until the fourth quarter. The dominant performance that he put on in leading his undersized, less talented Simeon squad to upset the top ranked team in the country marks just another chapter in the storied high school career that Derrick Rose had had so far.

It was clear from the tip that we were looking at the most explosive point guard that high school basketball has seen in recent memory. Rose’s combination of first step, leaping ability, and raw power have allow him to blow past anyone who attempted to guard him throughout the game. At 6’3 and 190 lbs., he already has a body superb to that of any point guard prospect for this years draft, and has the quickness and leaping ability to match. It is simply a thing of beauty to watch him get into the lane, absorb contact, and contort his body enough to gracefully finish at the rim. While we could go on for days about his marvelous athletic ability, there is far more to his game then that.


Against Oak Hill, Derrick came out gunning from the perimeter. As many know, that is definitely his biggest weakness and it seemed as if he was trying to make it a point to silence all of his critics. While he was unsuccessful in the majority of three point attempts, he did show improved form from the last time we saw him over the summer. It was clear to anyone watching the game however that shooting was surely not the strength of the Memphis signee’s game.

In terms of what you are looking for in a point guard, Rose has proven that he can fit the “scoring point guard” role just as well as he can the “pure point guard role”. His playmaking abilities were on display against Oak Hill as he finished with 9 assists, which would have easily been around 15 had his teammates been able to catch and/or finish his passes. Rose’s playmaking ability was never more evident then on his stunning left handed pass that most collegiate point guards couldn’t make with their right hands, which led to a Kevin Johnson slam dunk.

Defensively Derrick was fantastic throughout the game, no matter if he was guarding Jennings or Duke bound Nolan Smith. He used his fantastic athleticism and length to constantly stay in front of the two guards when guarding them, and was able to burst through the passing lanes a few times, leading to Simeon fast break points. Never more was it more clear that Rose has the potential to be an outstanding defender once he learns to defend at the collegiate level, which should surely happen upon his arrival at Memphis.

When writing about a player with such an abundance of strengths, it is often hard to pick out many weaknesses. Obviously, Rose’s outside shot, or lack thereof, is the only thing that has kept O.J. Mayo ahead of him as the consensus top player in the class of 2007. His brothers, who have shielded him mightily from the media until this past year, are not dumb and will surely find the best shooting coach money can buy for Derrick when it comes time for him to enter the NBA Draft. Rose’s handle could also use a little improvement in it’s consistency, as he can get a bit wild with his handle at times and dribbles a bit high. This is also partially in part due to Derrick’s love for the spectacular play, which he has the capability to give you on each and every possession. This can also be a downfall as well however, as shown by his breakaway slam

As far as the NBA is concerned, there have been rumors in the past of Derrick going and playing professionally overseas for a year or possibly going to the NBDL, which were immediately shot down by his camp. Memphis will be an outstanding fit for him, as their uptempo system will allow him to thrive. The Tigers should dominate C-USA yet again, as Rose should have four super athletes to join him in the starting five in Antonio Anderson, Chris Douglas-Roberts, Robert Dozier, and Joey Dorsey. With the Tigers’ style of play and Rose’s immense talent, it will be very surprising to see him stay in Memphis longer then a year and we should see him as a high lottery pick in 2008.

Brandon Jennings, 6’0, PG, Junior, Oak Hill Academy, Committed to USC
19 points (all in fourth quarter)

Mike Schmidt

After a good summer of AAU basketball, and a solid performance on national tv earlier this year, Brandon Jennings struggled against Simeon on Thursday night. Jennings ranks 6th in the country among juniors, and rates as the top point guard in his class. Over the summer, he ran the point on the So Cal All-Stars, which also featured Kevin Love, Renardo Sidney, and Taylor King. As good as his Oak Hill team is this season, the team he ran over the summer in AAU was that much better. With this team, Jennings did an outstanding job creating for teammates both in the half court and full court.

Thursday night Jennings struggled for much of the game, and didn’t look nearly as polished as he did over the summer. He did make a few flashy passes early in the game, including a cross court no-look pass in transition. Jennings couldn’t find his shot, however, and airballed a three early in the game. In the half court, he struggled to create many plays for his teammates, and spent a lot of the time sitting back and watching Alex Legion create. His play improved a little bit in the fourth quarter, but he took a number of bad three point shots off the dribble trying to get his team back into the game. At the end of the game Jennings sat on the bench crying on the sideline, but this game isn’t much a reflection on the talent that he possesses.

At this point in time, Brandon Jennings’ main strength is the ability he has to create shots for his teammates. He displayed flashes of this against Simeon, but he can usually do this throughout the game, and much more effectively in the half court. Jennings gets to the basket as well, and can finish pretty well, though he is improving in this area. As a shooter, he has a lot of room for improvement, but can make some long range shots from time to time. He will have to make some improvements to his ability to hit shots off the dribble, but this should develop more as he becomes more experienced. Another main weakness for Jennings is the fact that he always goes for the flashy play, and this leads to unnecessary turnovers.

Jennings is a player who’s not use to failing on the basketball court. The loss was the first of the season for Oak Hill, and he usually had comparable success in the AAU circuit with the So Cal All-Stars. He will have plenty of chances for redemption in the future, and one bad game shouldn’t effect the perception on Brandon Jennings as a player.

Alex Legion, 6’4, SG, Senior, Oak Hill Academy, Signed with Michigan
23 points, 9 rebounds

Rodger Bohn

The Detroit native led the way for Oak Hill, shooting the lights of the ball to the tune of 23 points on the evening. For a player who is such an explosive athlete, it was disappointing to see him not take the ball to the rim more often and constantly settling for contested perimeter jump shots. Legion has had a storied high school career, being on the national radar since before he arrived in high school and emerging as a top 10 prospect by his sophomore year. Since that point we have seen little improvement in his game and others have caught up to him physically, causing him to fall quite a bit in the national rankings.

It was clear to anyone watching the game that Legion will be able to immediately contribute at Michigan due to his ability to create his own shot and shoot the ball from the perimeter. He has no problem shooting off the dribble, on the move, or from a stand still. Aside from that though, he brings very little to the table. His ball handling skills are subpar at the moment, and he struggled mightily guarding Derrick Rose on the perimeter. Alex didn’t seem to have the lateral quickness, nor the fundamental defense necessary to guard a player of this caliber, evidenced by Rose’s collapse of the Oak Hill defense each and every time he looked to penetrate.

Next season at Michigan, the opportunity is certainly there for Legion to step in and play right away. With no sure fire starter at shooting guard, he is just a good a guess as anyone to get the majority of the minutes at off-guard. Not an immediate NBA prospect due to his lack of ideal size and ball handling skils, Alex will surely have the opportunity to market himself at Michigan, where he will be able to launch plenty of shots next season.

Nolan Smith, 6’3 PG/SG, Senior, Oak Hill Academy, Signed with Duke
12 points

Rodger Bohn

It was quite clear that Jennings and Legion were coming out with a vengence, leaving very little shots for the third member of the Oak Hill backcourt, Nolan Smith. The Duke bound senior played a solid, but unspectacular game in defeat, completely letting the game come to him and never forcing the issue, despite Oak Hill’s need for someone to step up in the third quarter when Simeon was building their lead up.

Smith’s transition from combo guard to full time point guard is still surely a work in progress. His ball handling and defense can still use tons of improvement, and he doesn’t have the natural playmaking ability that you would like to see out of a player looking to run one of the top college teams in the country next season.


On the bright side, Nolan is very intriguing as a combo guard and should be able to put up nice scoring numbers immediately upon his arrival in Durham. He is a deceptively explosive athlete and is one of the more cerebral players on the high school level, playing with the savvy of a college sophomore. The son of former NBA player Derek Smith has good court vision and passing ability, but again lacks the natural playmaking ability to play point guard full time at this moment. Within a few years however, it is certainly not out of the question for Smith to have emerged as a Daniel Ewing type prospect, one who is better suited for the shooting guard position but has adequate enough playmaking ability to run point when need be.

Julian Vaughn, 6’9, PF, Senior, Oak Hill Academy, Signed with Florida State

Mike Schmidt

Julian Vaughn had a good summer playing AAU, but has struggled in both games he’s played on national tv. this season. Vaughn is the 52nd ranked player in the class of 2007, and plans to play at Florida State next season. Over the summer he displayed the ability to step out and hit the college three pointer on a regular basis. He also displayed a developing post game inside, and the ability to alter shots on the defensive end. He played on a loaded team that included Michael Beasley, Nolan Smith, and Austin Freeman, and looked like he had a lot of potential to improve.

In both televised Oak Hill games this year, Vaughn has looked a lot less athletic than he did over the summer. He seems to be less mobile now, and it looks like he favors his right knee. This affects his play inside, as he doesn’t really try to create his own offense with his back to the basket. The majority of his points for Oak Hill seem to come from offensive rebounds, and chip shots inside. Vaughn also hasn’t been stepping out and hitting three point shots like he did on the summer circuit. In terms of mobility, he struggled to adjust inside after catching the ball, and missed a few shots near that basket that he should have been able to dunk.

He did block some shots inside against Simeon, and his rebounding fundamentals appear to be solid at this point. Vaughn has good length, and his ability to alter shots will improve if he can regain some explosiveness.

It’s tough to say what Julian Vaughn will bring to Florida State next season. If he is indeed bothered by an injury, a summer of rehab would do wonders for his game. If he can play like he did over the summer, he should get minutes from day 1.

Kevin Johnson, 6’7, PF, Senior, Chicago Simeon, Signed with Wisconsin-Milwaukee
18 points, 10 rebounds

Mike Schmidt

Kevin Johnson played well against Oak Hill, and looks like the type of player who can succeed playing the Horizon League. Johnson displayed a good level of athleticism, and he applies it very well on the court. He finishes strong inside, and also out-jumps a lot of players for rebounds. Johnson also displayed the ability to step out and hit the mid-range jump shot. He appears to stand a legit 6’7” off the ground, and has a good body for a highs school big man.

Johnson looks like he sometimes struggles against taller players who can match his athleticism. He doesn’t look like the kind of guy who is going to create a ton of offense for himself right away, and his game inside looks a little limited at this point. In the Horizon League, this will not be a huge problem.

Johnson and fellow Simeon teammate Tim Flowers will both play at UW-Milwaukee next season. They should help the team in the rebuilding process to get back to where they were a couple of years ago. Both big men should be able to handle spot minutes right away, and it will be interesting to watch them develop over the course of their 4 years.

Recent articles

8.0 Points
1.9 Rebounds
3.3 Assists
13.1 PER
6.7 Points
2.7 Rebounds
4.0 Assists
17.4 PER
10.2 Points
2.4 Rebounds
6.4 Assists
11.0 PER
4.0 Points
1.0 Rebounds
1.5 Assists
6.5 PER
7.6 Points
2.3 Rebounds
0.6 Assists
12.3 PER
4.8 Points
1.0 Rebounds
1.6 Assists
0.4 PER
19.0 Points
4.3 Rebounds
2.0 Assists
16.2 PER
16.0 Points
8.3 Rebounds
2.0 Assists
30.2 PER
14.2 Points
11.7 Rebounds
2.9 Assists
21.7 PER
8.4 Points
5.8 Rebounds
1.9 Assists
18.8 PER
9.3 Points
5.0 Rebounds
0.0 Assists
14.2 PER
2.8 Points
2.8 Rebounds
0.2 Assists
6.4 PER
2.5 Points
0.0 Rebounds
2.5 Assists
13.5 PER
5.8 Points
2.2 Rebounds
1.2 Assists
11.4 PER
11.0 Points
6.0 Rebounds
1.0 Assists
15.7 PER
7.7 Points
3.0 Rebounds
2.3 Assists
8.3 PER

Twitter @DraftExpress

DraftExpress Shop